In a move to address the pressing concerns surrounding Australia’s food and grocery industry, the government has embarked on a mission to fortify the nation’s supermarket giants with a more robust regulatory framework. The catalyst for this transformation is a government-commissioned review led by former Labor competition minister and renowned economist Dr Craig Emerson, who has been entrusted with the critical task of reevaluating the Food and Grocery Industry Code of Conduct.
This timely review has been instigated in response to mounting apprehensions that the existing regulatory structure lacks the muscle required to cope with the surging cost-of-living crisis. Australians have been grappling with escalating expenses, and it is imperative that measures be taken to safeguard both consumers and suppliers in this vital sector.
In an effort to foster greater competition within the supermarket industry, Dr. Emerson emphasises the importance of holding supermarkets accountable for their actions. He insists that it is through robust competition that we can achieve the dual objectives of fair prices for suppliers and affordable groceries for consumers. Dr. Emerson underscores a pervasive concern that compliance with the current code is often perceived as voluntary, necessitating a comprehensive review.
One of the focal points of this review is the consideration of augmented financial penalties to be imposed on supermarket giants for any breaches of the forthcoming industry code of conduct. While the existing penalties already entail fines of up to $187,000, the consultation paper raises the possibility of reevaluating the magnitude of these fines in light of the significant market dominance of major supermarket chains. The document candidly acknowledges that to act as an effective deterrent, substantially higher financial penalties may be warranted.
Furthermore, the review will meticulously assess the effectiveness of the current, albeit optional, code in ameliorating relationships among retailers, wholesalers, and suppliers. There is also a contemplation of whether the code should be entirely overhauled and rebuilt from the ground up. This initiative signifies a pivotal moment in Australia’s grocery industry, with the potential for profound implications for its stakeholders.
The consultation paper does not stop there. It also delves into the critical issue of bargaining power imbalances between supermarkets and their suppliers. It questions whether the current regulatory framework adequately addresses these imbalances and whether it has alleviated suppliers’ fears of retribution when they raise concerns.
Highlighting the concentration of market power, the document reveals that Woolworths, Coles, Aldi, and IGA supplier Metcash collectively hold over 80% of the Australian market. In contrast, the top two companies in the UK command a 43% market share, and the top four players in the US account for just 34%. This startling contrast underscores the need for Australia to reassess its regulatory approach.
As the review seeks to strengthen the industry, it takes inspiration from international models, such as the UK’s Groceries Code Adjudicator and New Zealand’s Code of Conduct, offering valuable insights into how other nations have tackled similar challenges.
Intriguingly, the consultation paper points to past recommendations by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, which have advocated replacing the voluntary code with a mandatory one. This signals a clear intention to bolster the code’s enforcement and effectiveness.
Coinciding with this review, Treasurer Jim Chalmers has enlisted the consumer watchdog to investigate pricing and competition in the supermarket sector, demonstrating a concerted effort by the government to ensure fairness and competitiveness in the industry.
In a bid to make this regulatory overhaul as comprehensive and well-informed as possible, the government is actively seeking public feedback and soliciting information on how the code of conduct can be fortified and rendered more potent. This is a pivotal moment in the evolution of Australia’s food and grocery industry, one that holds the potential to benefit both consumers and suppliers alike.